A good electric roaster oven frees your main oven for sides, holds a whole turkey, and keeps food warm until everyone sits down. These three picks cover the classic 18 quart size and two larger 22 quart models, with the capacity, temperature range, and lid design that matter most on Thanksgiving.
Affiliate Disclosure: Some links on this page may be affiliate links. EverydayRated plans to participate in affiliate marketing programs; when those programs are active, purchases made through links on this site may earn us a commission at no additional cost to you. Our recommendations are based on independent research, never on commissions.
Quick answer: choose the Nesco 18-Qt Roaster Oven if you want the proven classic for a turkey up to 22 pounds, the Hamilton Beach 22-Qt Roaster Oven if you regularly cook the largest birds up to 28 pounds, and the Oster 22-Qt Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid if you want hands off moisture control for a turkey up to 26 pounds.
Everyday Ratings are research-based editorial scores based on published specifications, independent reviews, owner feedback, and typical value. These products were not personally hands-on tested by EverydayRated. Prices and availability change frequently.
Quick Answer
Nesco 18-Qt Roaster Oven
4.6 / 5
Best for most Thanksgiving cooks and turkeys up to 22 pounds.
Hamilton Beach 22-Qt Roaster Oven
4.5 / 5
Best for large gatherings and turkeys up to 28 pounds.
Oster 22-Qt Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid
4.3 / 5
Best for hands off cooking and turkeys up to 26 pounds.
How We Evaluated
Last Reviewed: November 2026. We scored each roaster on usable capacity and turkey fit, temperature range and control, lid design, removable parts and cleanup, and value at the checked price. Scores weigh published specifications, manuals, retailer listings, and owner feedback, not hands-on testing, so check the vendor listing for current stock, included accessories, and warranty terms before you buy.
Best Electric Roaster Ovens at a Glance
| Pick | Checked price | Best for | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best Overall: Nesco 18-Qt Roaster Oven | $89.99 at Wayfair, checked November 1, 2026 | Most Thanksgiving cooks, turkeys up to 22 pounds | 4.6 / 5 |
| Best for Large Turkeys: Hamilton Beach 22-Qt Roaster Oven | Check the vendor listing | Large gatherings, turkeys up to 28 pounds | 4.5 / 5 |
| Best Self-Basting Lid: Oster 22-Qt Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid | Check the vendor listing | Hands off cooking, turkeys up to 26 pounds | 4.3 / 5 |
1. Nesco 18-Qt Roaster Oven
EverydayRated score: 4.6 / 5
Key specifications: 18 quart capacity; roasts a turkey up to 22 pounds; 1450 watt base; temperature control from 200°F to 450°F; removable porcelain enamel cookwell; cooking rack with lift-out handles.
The Nesco 18-Qt is the long running classic in this category, and its specifications explain why it still earns the top spot. NESCO describes a 1450 watt base with Circle of Heat heating, a domed lid for air circulation, and a removable 18 quart cookwell that holds a turkey up to 22 pounds, with full range temperature control from 200°F to 450°F for roasting, baking, steaming, slow cooking, and serving. [1] That combination covers the main Thanksgiving job plus year round uses such as ham, pulled pork, brisket, chili, and baked sides, without asking you to learn a new control system.
Fit is the practical advantage of the 18 quart size. It is large enough for the turkey most households buy, yet smaller and easier to store than the 22 quart models below. Before you order, measure your counter and storage space, and confirm your bird’s weight and shape against the 22 pound limit, since a tall breast can matter as much as total weight. The rack with lift-out handles helps with the awkward lift from roaster to platter, and the porcelain enamel finish is meant to wipe clean after cooking.
On value, the checked price was competitive for a name brand roaster with this track record. Wayfair listed the Nesco 18 Qt. Roaster Oven at $89.99, down from $99.99, with a 4.8 star owner rating from 209 votes at the time of the check. [2] Target listed the black 18 quart model at $99.99 in the same check, so color and retailer can change what you pay. [3] The 4.6 score reflects strong capacity for its size, simple controls, and verified specifications, held back only by the smaller turkey limit compared with the 22 quart picks and by holiday stock swings.
What to know before Thanksgiving
Plan on a meat thermometer rather than time alone, and let the turkey rest before carving. NESCO notes that a traditional roaster cooks at about 15 to 20 minutes per pound, with extra time for a stuffed bird, and that the meat should reach 165 degrees at the thickest part. Roaster oven skin also tends to brown less than oven roasted skin, so if crisp skin matters to you, finish the bird briefly under a hot oven or use a browning sauce as NESCO suggests, and confirm the approach in the included care and use guide.
- Proven 18 quart design with a 22 pound turkey capacity that suits most households.
- Wide 200°F to 450°F range for roasting, baking, steaming, and slow cooking.
- Removable porcelain enamel cookwell and lift-out rack handles for easier serving and cleanup.
- Smaller than 22 quart models, so it will not suit the largest turkeys.
- Skin may brown less than in a conventional oven without a finishing step.
- Price varies by color and retailer, and holiday stock can sell out quickly.
It is the safest default pick: verified capacity, a wide temperature range, simple controls, and a checked sale price, in a size that fits most kitchens and most turkeys.
2. Hamilton Beach 22-Qt Roaster Oven
EverydayRated score: 4.5 / 5
Key specifications: 22 quart capacity; holds a 28 lb turkey; temperature range listed at 125°F to 450°F; stainless steel exterior; removable cooking pan and included lift-out rack.
If your guest list regularly pushes past a 20 pound bird, the Hamilton Beach 22-Qt is the capacity pick. Do it Best describes a versatile 22 quart roaster that holds a 28 lb turkey, doubles oven space, and handles large meats as well as steaming, baking, slow cooking, and keeping food warm, with one knob adjusting temperature from 125°F to 450°F. [4] The removable cooking pan lifts out for cleaning, and the included lift-out rack is designed to move a large ham or turkey from roaster to platter with less wrestling.
The extra capacity also helps beyond the turkey. Hamilton Beach notes that the 22 quart size can make 2 pounds of party meatballs or 5 quarts of chili, which makes this model useful for batch cooking and buffet serving long after Thanksgiving. [5] That flexibility is worth real counter space only if you host often or cook in volume, since a 22 quart roaster is a large appliance to store. Measure the footprint, check lid clearance under cabinets, and confirm the pan and rack fit your sink for washing.
We could not verify a current price on a fetched retailer product page on November 1, 2026, so no price number appears for this pick. That is why the score sits at 4.5 rather than higher: the capacity, temperature range, and included rack are strong, but value cannot be judged until you see the live vendor price, and holiday pricing on large roasters moves quickly. The use and care guidance for this model family also warns that some smoke and odor can occur on first use, so run a first heat cycle with ventilation before the holiday, and follow the manual for washing the pan, rack, and lid before first use. [6]
Best use on the day
Use this roaster for the turkey and let your main oven handle sides, which is the core benefit of any large roaster. Keep the lid closed as much as possible to hold heat and moisture, check doneness with a thermometer, and use the keep warm function for serving rather than holding food at serving temperature for longer than food safety guidance allows. Confirm the exact model number and included parts on the vendor listing, since Hamilton Beach sells several similar roasters.
- Largest turkey capacity in this guide at 28 pounds, with 22 quarts of space.
- Wide listed temperature range from 125°F to 450°F for warming through roasting.
- Removable pan and lift-out rack for easier cleaning and serving of large meats.
- Large footprint and storage needs compared with the 18 quart Nesco.
- Current price could not be verified on a fetched retailer page, so check before buying.
- Some smoke and odor may occur on first use, so plan a test run.
It is the straightforward choice when 18 quarts is not enough: verified 22 quart capacity, a 28 pound turkey limit, and a rack built for heavy roasts.
3. Oster 22-Qt Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid
EverydayRated score: 4.3 / 5
Key specifications: 22 quart capacity; accommodates turkeys up to 26 pounds; variable temperature dial from 150°F to 450°F with Keep Warm and Defrost settings; removable enamel-on-steel roasting pan and roasting rack; dimensions 23.3 inches long by 15.6 inches wide by 11.8 inches high.
The Oster 22-Qt earns its place on the strength of its lid. The instruction manual describes a roaster built for roasting, baking, and slow cooking, with a self-basting lid and removable parts for ease of use and cleaning, plus a variable temperature dial from 150°F to 450°F with Keep Warm and Defrost settings. [7] In practice, the lid is designed to recirculate moisture so you baste less often, which helps when you are juggling sides and do not want to open the roaster repeatedly.
Capacity sits between the other two picks: 22 quarts, with room for a turkey up to 26 pounds, plus a removable enamel-on-steel pan and rack. The manual lists dimensions of 23.3 inches long by 15.6 inches wide by 11.8 inches high, so check those measurements against your counter and storage shelf, and check lid height with your actual turkey, since a high domed lid still has limits. [8] The Defrost setting is a useful extra for this category, but it does not replace safe thawing time in the refrigerator, so plan thawing days ahead.
As with the Hamilton Beach pick, we could not verify a current price on a fetched manufacturer or major retailer product page on November 1, 2026, so no price number appears here. Owner feedback summarized in independent reviews points to the same tradeoffs seen across this category: moist results and easy cleanup on the plus side, with bulkier storage and less crisp skin than a conventional oven on the minus side. The 4.3 score reflects strong capacity and a genuinely useful lid, tempered by the unverified price and by the need to confirm current stock and the exact model, CKSTRS23-SB, on the vendor listing.
How to get the most from the lid
Resist lifting the lid to peek, since each lift releases heat and moisture that the self-basting design is trying to keep in. Preheat for 15 to 20 minutes as the manual directs, place food on the rack inside the pan, and rely on a thermometer for doneness. If you want crisper skin, plan a short finish in a hot oven after the turkey is cooked through, and let it rest before carving.
- Self-basting lid recirculates moisture and reduces hands on basting.
- 22 quart capacity for turkeys up to 26 pounds, with Keep Warm and Defrost settings.
- Removable enamel-on-steel pan and rack for easier cleanup.
- Current price could not be verified on a fetched retailer page, so check before buying.
- Bulky to store, and skin may brown less than in a conventional oven.
- Confirm the exact model number and included parts, since Oster sells similar roasters.
The self-basting lid is the most useful hands off feature in this guide, paired with large capacity and practical Keep Warm and Defrost settings.
Buyer’s Guide: Electric Roaster Ovens
1. Match capacity to your turkey, not just the guest count
Quart size and turkey weight are related but not identical, so check both numbers. An 18 quart roaster that holds a 22 pound turkey suits most households, while 22 quart models in this guide hold 26 to 28 pounds. Weigh your bird, check its shape and breast height, and leave room for the lid to close fully.
2. Check temperature range and warming settings
Look for a range that covers low warming through high roasting, roughly 150°F to 450°F on the models here, with a Keep Warm setting for serving. A single dial is normal in this category, so expect approximate control rather than precise oven style accuracy, and always verify doneness with a thermometer.
3. Lid design, pan, and cleanup matter on the day
A domed or self-basting lid helps hold moisture and fit taller birds, while a removable pan and lift-out rack make serving and washing far easier. Confirm whether the pan and rack are dishwasher safe on the vendor listing, check that they fit your sink, and plan storage space for the lid and base together.
4. Measure, test, and confirm before the holiday
Measure counter space, lid clearance, outlet location, and storage before ordering, since roasters are wide and tall. Do a first run with ventilation to clear any new appliance odor, confirm stock and included accessories, and check warranty terms on the vendor listing. Prices move quickly near Thanksgiving, so recheck the price on the day you buy.
Related Thanksgiving Buying Guides
EverydayRated Verdict
Buy the Nesco 18-Qt Roaster Oven if you want the proven classic at a verified sale price for turkeys up to 22 pounds. Buy the Hamilton Beach 22-Qt if you need the largest capacity for a 28 pound bird and frequent large gatherings. Buy the Oster 22-Qt with Self-Basting Lid if hands off moisture control and Keep Warm and Defrost settings matter most, and you are cooking a turkey up to 26 pounds.
Whichever model you choose, confirm the turkey fit, the current price, stock, included parts, and warranty terms on the vendor listing before you buy, and use a thermometer for doneness. A roaster oven earns its keep by freeing your main oven, but only if it fits your bird, your counter, and your storage space.
Sources and Research
- NESCO, Category: Cooking, 18 Qt. Roaster Oven description: 1450 watt base, Circle of Heat, 18 quart cookwell, turkey up to 22 pounds, 200°F to 450°F control, porcelain enamel finish, rack with lift-out handles.
- Wayfair listing page: Nesco 18 Qt. Roaster Oven listed at $89.99, down from $99.99, rated 4.8 stars from 209 votes at the time of the check.
- Target listing page: Nesco 18qt Roaster Black listed at $99.99.
- Do it Best, Hamilton Beach 22 Qt. Stainless Steel Electric Roaster Oven with Black Lid: 22 quart capacity, 28 lb turkey, 125°F to 450°F, removable pan, lift-out rack.
- Hamilton Beach, 6 Surprising Ways to Use Your Roaster Oven: 22 quart capacity, 2 pounds of party meatballs or 5 quarts of chili.
- Manuals.plus, Hamilton Beach 32229R Roaster Oven Instruction Manual: first use smoke and odor guidance, washing guidance, and roasting guidance.
- Manuals.plus, Oster CKSTRS23-SB 22-Quart Roaster Oven Instruction Manual: self-basting lid, removable pan and rack, 150°F to 450°F dial with Keep Warm and Defrost settings.
- Manua.ls, User manual Oster CKSTRS23-SB-D: model identification, dimensions, and roaster oven use guidance.
Research checked November 1, 2026.
Generated artwork illustrates generic product types and does not show verified photographs of the recommended models.